Overview
The complexity and potential long term ramifications arising from insurance coverage litigation not only requires a global understanding of insurance law, but often demands a creative and innovative problem solving approach.
Reminger's insurance coverage group offers a variety of services to our clients when confronted with insurance coverage issues. We offer advice in drafting policy language to effectively address some of the unique nuances of Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana law. We also provide counsel in the recognition and resolution of coverage issues, including representation in all types of insurance coverage litigation and the defense of bad faith and other extra contractual claims. Our expertise and experience in insurance coverage matters covers both first party and third party insurance policies, including specialized insurance products issued to either individuals, small businesses or large corporations, and professional entities.
Our firm has the capacity and experience to represent insurance carriers on cutting edge insurance issues. Some recent examples of our representation involve the defense of the application of the intentional act exclusion relative to derivative liability claims, application of the standard and absolute pollution exclusion, determination of the number of occurrences and allocation issues arising from catastrophic losses, and application of notice provisions in both occurrence and claims made policies. We are proud to be involved in the adjudication of important insurance coverage issues in state supreme courts on multiple occasions.
We have members of the insurance coverage group represented in each of our offices for effective representation on all insurance coverage concerns. Our practice group co-chair currently serves an officer of the EC Defense Network, which was established to provide a nationwide network of attorneys specializing in the defense of insurance companies against bad faith claims.
Honors & Recognitions
Reminger’s Insurance Coverage/Bad Faith Group was ranked by Best Lawyers® as National Tier 3, and at the Metropolitan level in Cleveland, Cincinnati, Fort Wayne, and Columbus for 2025.
Representative Clients
AIG, Allianz Global Risks, American Modern Home Insurance, American National Property Insurance and Casualty, CNA, Certain Underwriters at Lloyds, Cincinnati Insurance Company, ESurance, Fireman’s Fund Insurance Company, General Star Management Company, Great American Insurance Company, Great West Casualty Company, Insurance Environmental Litigation Association, Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company, Monitor Liability Managers, National Chiropractic Mutual Insurance, Old Republic Companies, One Beacon Insurance Company, SOMPO International, Swiss RE, Travelers Insurance Company, Voya Financial, and various London market companies.
Testimonials
“I am very impressed with Reminger’s coverage expertise. The lawyers are a pleasure to work with, which goes a long way. Clifford Masch is simply great.”
Rachel, Assistant Vice President and Senior Claims Counsel
Results
- Nov 5, 2024, Motion to Dismiss GrantedVigo County Superior Court
Motion to dismiss granted in favor of residential real estate appraisers accused of negligence.
- Sep 25, 2024, DismissalBucks County, PA
Suit was dismissed against Insurer in small claims trial related to blasting work performed by Insured.
- Aug 21, 2024, Summary JudgmentMarion County, IN
A nationwide provider of training and continuing education courses to members of law enforcement and public safety alleged that our insurance agent failed to advise them of event cancellation insurance and failed to procure insurance to cover the cancellation of any the seminar/classes they had across the nation. The Court granted summary judgment in favor of our client based on the statute of limitations.
- Aug 21, 2024, Motion For Summary JudgmentIndiana Commercial Court
Obtained summary Judgment in favor of insurance agent based on claims of a failure to advise regarding insurance coverage.
- May 10, 2024, Defense VerdictJasper County, IN Circuit Court
Obtained jury verdict in favor of insurer in coverage claim.
- Jul 2023, Defense VerdictJefferson County Kentucky Circuit Court
Obtained defense verdict in a two-day personal injury and UIM jury trial arising from a multi-vehicle collision which involved a fatality.
- Nov 14, 2022, Appeal Dismissed4th Appellate Dist
Defense of an insurance broker who secured insurance for a chemical storage tank manufacturer. The tank manufacturer was sued by four plaintiffs alleging injury from exposure to benzene via their faulty tanks with alleged exposure dating back to the 1970’s and 1980’s.
- Oct 26, 2022U.S. District Court of Ohio, Northern District
Motion for summary judgment granted by Northern District of Ohio in insurance coverage matter regarding the scope of tortfeasor’s employment.
- Aug 30, 2021Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals
After obtaining dismissal of negligent claims against an insurance agent/broker of disability insurance based contributory negligence pursuant to choice of law and statute of limitations, the judgment was affirmed on appeal after oral argument.
- Wohleber v. SkurkoNov 18, 2020, Dismissal6th Circuit Court of Appeals
Dismissed appeal for lack of jurisdiction because Bankruptcy Appellate Panel’s order remanding for completion of liability phase was not final for purposes of 28 U.S.C. § 158(d)(1).
- Oct 13, 2020, Summary Judgment GrantedMarion Superior Court
Successfully obtained summary judgment for life insurance agency for failing to procure and maintain life insurance for the plaintiff’s deceased husband based on the expiration of the statute of limitations.
- Aug 18, 2020, Summary Judgment GrantedU.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana
Successfully obtained summary judgment on behalf of insurance company regarding coverage dispute.
- Jun 15, 2020Hamilton County Municipal Court
Defendant mental health services and housing to individuals with mental health issues. Defendant filed an eviction case against the resident Plaintiff for non-payment of rent. Plaintiff filed a pro se Counterclaim alleging entitlement to the security deposit, as well as alleging property damage and physical injury. Eviction was granted and magistrate dismissed Plaintiff's counterclaim.
- Jan 15, 2020, Motion For Summary JudgmentPulaski County Superior Court
Obtained summary judgment on behalf of insurance agency defending claims of negligent failure to write appropriate insurance.
- May 22, 2019, Summary JudgmentMorgan County Superior Court (Indiana)
Successfully obtained summary judgment on behalf of an insurance agent and insurance carrier facing claims of negligence and breach of contract, respectively.
- Mar 28, 2019U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana
Obtained dismissal on behalf of a a broker of disability insurance facing claims of negligent procurement of insurance.
- Oct 23, 2018, Judgment GrantedU.S. District Court, Southern District of Ohio
Obtained a judgment in the amount of $3 million in an insurance coverage dispute.
- Jul 21, 2017, Partial Summary Judgment GrantedU.S. District Court, Northern District of Ohio
Successful insurance coverage matter regarding duty to defend and indemnify.
- Aug 23, 2016, DismissalU.S. District Court, Southern District of Ohio
Early dismissal of insurance agency on claims of negligence and malpractice for lack of federal jurisdiction
- Mar 7, 2014, Motion to Sever Third Party Claims GrantedUnited States District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania
Granting motion to sever third party claims against title insurance agent in class action alleging improper application of title insurance rate
- Oct 11, 2013, Judgment Affirmed6th Circuit Court of Appeals
Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Company v. Youth Alive, Inc.
Defendant appealed adverse trial court judgment of denial of insurance coverage
- Jul 29, 2013Lake
Defense of declaratory judgment action for denial of coverage
- Apr 3, 2013, Judgment on the Pleadings grantedTrumbull
Defense of insurance coverage claim involving damage to insured dwelling during burglary
- Feb 21, 2013, Affirmed10th Appellate Dist
N. Jackson-Brown, Admrx. of E/O E. Brown v. United States Liability Insurance Co.
Third-Party Plaintiff appealed denial of insurance coverage for liquor liability based upon the assault, battery and firearms exclusion from adverse trial court judgment.
- Feb 12, 2013Lorain
Prosecution of subrogation claim for failure of defendant to properly size a sewer by-pass pump resulting in sewage backup.
- Nov 19, 2012Boone County, KY
Defense of uninsured motorist personal injury liability claim
- Hicks v. Mennonite Mutual InsuranceJan 27, 2012, Judgment ReversedMiami
Defense of insurance coverage bad faith claim. Reversing judgment of trial court granting summary judgment in favor of defendant insurer on plaintiff’s breach of contract and bad faith claims.
- Nov 11, 2011, Reversed and Remanded2nd Appellate Dist
Charles J. Ozvath v. The Buckeye Union Insurance Company
Defendant appealed adverse trial court’s finding of coverage of duty to defend and attorney fees.
- Nov 10, 2010, Reversed and Remanded5th Appellate Dist
Emery Conn, et al. v. I.G. Concrete Inc. and Maxum Indemnity Company
Client appealed adverse trial court judgment regarding default from a void judgment.
- Sep 23, 2010, Plaintiff VerdictLucas
Defense of catastrophic fire property damage and lost profits claim
- Oct 8, 2009, Favorable OutcomeMontgomery
Defense of coverage duty to defense claim.
News
News
Events
Insights
Publications
Reminger Reports
Main Contacts
- ChairCleveland
- Ft. Mitchell
- Columbus
- Indianapolis
- Louisville
- Youngstown
- Lexington
All Practice Group Attorneys
- Brian D. Sullivan
- Joseph Borchelt
- Mark R. Bush
- Melvin J. Davis
- Logan C. Hughes
- B. Scott Jones
- Thomas A. Prislipsky
- J. Kelly Ratliff
- Vincent P. Antaki
- Alex M. Beeman
- Steven A. Chang
- Mario C. Ciano
- Andrew J. Dorman
- Tighe A. Estes
- Katherine M. Haire
- Andrew Haughey
- Lyndsay I. Ignasiak
- Jennifer J. Jandes
- Lindsay M. Johnson
- Tommy Kaczkowski
- Patrick Kasson
- Suzanne F. Kleinedler
- Nathan A. Lennon
- Steven Lowery
- Charles J. Maiers
- Michael P. Murphy
- Brianna Prislipsky
- Michael D. Rice
- Austin Richards
- Stephanie D. Ross
- James P. Scheidler
- Timothy B. Spille
- Thomas N. Spyker
- Carrie Masters Starts
- Jade A. Stewart
- James J. Turek
- Meredith Turner-Woolley
- Julie Grace VanVliet
- Robert A. West, Jr.
- Chad E. Willits